Popular Supernatural Jigsaw Puzzles

90 results
Create your own product
Barnum and Bailey - Supernatural Illusions, 1898 Jigsaw Puzzle
Barnum and Bailey - Supernatural Illusions, 1898 Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$39.25
Supernatural Cat at the Great Wave Jigsaw Puzzle
Supernatural Cat at the Great Wave Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$38.80
Weird & Wonderful Supernatural Illusions In Hall Jigsaw Puzzle
Weird & Wonderful Supernatural Illusions In Hall Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$87.85
Circe Invidiosa by John William Waterhouse Jigsaw Puzzle
Circe Invidiosa by John William Waterhouse Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$87.85
SlipperyJoe's mystical Halloween-style atmosphere Jigsaw Puzzle
SlipperyJoe's mystical Halloween-style atmosphere Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$118.00
SlipperyJoe's mystical Halloween-style atmosphere Jigsaw Puzzle
SlipperyJoe's mystical Halloween-style atmosphere Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$58.55
The Lady in Red Gothic Art Puzzle Collection
The Lady in Red Gothic Art Puzzle Collection
Price$79.85
VII The Dollmaker's Den – Not Just Dolls, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
VII The Dollmaker's Den – Not Just Dolls, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$82.70
XX The Parlour of Regret – Sit and Weep, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
XX The Parlour of Regret – Sit and Weep, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$82.70
Mystical Flowers of the Supernatural Realm Jigsaw Puzzle
Mystical Flowers of the Supernatural Realm Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$114.00
Wedding Collection
Infernal Temptress" Jigsaw Puzzle
Infernal Temptress" Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$37.05
Helsing design puzzle
Helsing design puzzle
Price$36.95
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.06 Simizukanjya Yoshitaka - Jigsaw Puzzle
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.06 Simizukanjya Yoshitaka - Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$111.00
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.20 Kikuchi Kazumaru - Jigsaw Puzzle
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.20 Kikuchi Kazumaru - Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$111.00
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.01 Jiraiya - Jigsaw Puzzle
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.01 Jiraiya - Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$111.00
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.01 Jiraiya - Jigsaw Puzzle
ukiyoe - Toyokuni - No.01 Jiraiya - Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$35.10
Puzzle The Dark Labyrinth
Puzzle The Dark Labyrinth
Price$74.00
Fantasy Floating World Jigsaw Puzzle
Fantasy Floating World Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$118.00
Celestial creatures angel demon fantasy jigsaw puzzle
Celestial creatures angel demon fantasy jigsaw puzzle
Price$111.00
Dynamic Fantasy Werewolf Under Dramatic Moonlight Jigsaw Puzzle
Dynamic Fantasy Werewolf Under Dramatic Moonlight Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$37.05
Angelic Spirit Praying in Holy Unknown Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Angelic Spirit Praying in Holy Unknown Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$78.10
Heavenly Angel Hovers Above Mysterious Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Heavenly Angel Hovers Above Mysterious Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$78.10
Dynamic Fantasy Vampire in Dramatic Nocturnal Atmo Jigsaw Puzzle
Dynamic Fantasy Vampire in Dramatic Nocturnal Atmo Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$37.05
Chupacabra in the Woods Cryptid Jigsaw Puzzle
Chupacabra in the Woods Cryptid Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Bigfoot Sasquatch in the Woods Jigsaw Puzzle
Bigfoot Sasquatch in the Woods Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Dark Overlord in Ancient Temple in Charge Jigsaw Puzzle
Dark Overlord in Ancient Temple in Charge Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Ancient Spirit in Beamed Down in Mystical Temple Jigsaw Puzzle
Ancient Spirit in Beamed Down in Mystical Temple Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Gothic Death Skull and Roses Floral Sigil Jigsaw Puzzle
Gothic Death Skull and Roses Floral Sigil Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$77.55
Creepy Statue of an Unknown Cephalopod Jigsaw Puzzle
Creepy Statue of an Unknown Cephalopod Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$116.00
VIII The Widow’s Watch – Still Waiting, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
VIII The Widow’s Watch – Still Waiting, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$82.70
Beautiful Dark and Gothic Roses Skull Sigil Jigsaw Puzzle
Beautiful Dark and Gothic Roses Skull Sigil Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$77.55
Werewolves Zombie Jigsaw Puzzle
Werewolves Zombie Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$118.00
Surreal Robed Spirit in Ancient Mystical Temple Jigsaw Puzzle
Surreal Robed Spirit in Ancient Mystical Temple Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Ancient Eldtich Horror: Deep Ocean Kraken Jigsaw Puzzle
Ancient Eldtich Horror: Deep Ocean Kraken Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$116.00
Witches' Sabbath by Francisco de Goya Jigsaw Puzzle
Witches' Sabbath by Francisco de Goya Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$41.70
Gothic Skull Art: Creepy Death Metal Sigil Jigsaw Puzzle
Gothic Skull Art: Creepy Death Metal Sigil Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$115.00
IXX Clocktower Collapse – Time's Up, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
IXX Clocktower Collapse – Time's Up, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$82.70
Chupacabra - Cryptid Monsters or Animals Jigsaw Puzzle
Chupacabra - Cryptid Monsters or Animals Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Holy Unknown Glowing Angel in Mysterious Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Holy Unknown Glowing Angel in Mysterious Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$78.10
Angelic Figure Praying in Holy Mysterious Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Angelic Figure Praying in Holy Mysterious Garden Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$78.10
Robed Ancient Being in Otherworldly Surroundings Jigsaw Puzzle
Robed Ancient Being in Otherworldly Surroundings Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Otherworldly Spirit with Glowing Eyes in Universe Jigsaw Puzzle
Otherworldly Spirit with Glowing Eyes in Universe Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
Midnight Haunting - Spooky Old House Jigsaw Puzzle
Midnight Haunting - Spooky Old House Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$37.05
The Magic Circle John William Waterhouse Art Jigsaw Puzzle
The Magic Circle John William Waterhouse Art Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$121.00
Night Witch Starry Night Illustration Jigsaw Puzzle
Night Witch Starry Night Illustration Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$41.70
XXI Whispering Hearth – Warm Lies, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
XXI Whispering Hearth – Warm Lies, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$82.70
Olive Trees by Vincent Van Gogh Jigsaw Puzzle
Olive Trees by Vincent Van Gogh Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$78.10
UFO Extraterrestrial Abduction Alien Jigsaw Puzzle
UFO Extraterrestrial Abduction Alien Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$108.00
alligator people jigsaw puzzle
alligator people jigsaw puzzle
Price$31.40
Black Child Angel Floral Art Jigsaw Puzzle
Black Child Angel Floral Art Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$113.00
Falln On Watch Jigsaw Puzzle
Falln On Watch Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$39.25
Falln Between Darkness and Light Jigsaw Puzzle
Falln Between Darkness and Light Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$39.25
XV The Bloodline Estate – Family Stains, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
XV The Bloodline Estate – Family Stains, Tarot Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$82.70
Creepy Statue of an Ancient Alien Entity Jigsaw Puzzle
Creepy Statue of an Ancient Alien Entity Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$116.00
A Man's Near Death Experience & Gothic Spirits Jigsaw Puzzle
A Man's Near Death Experience & Gothic Spirits Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$84.70
The Witches' Sabbath, Las Brujas by Francisco de G Jigsaw Puzzle
The Witches' Sabbath, Las Brujas by Francisco de G Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$41.70
Dark Alien Statue of an Ancient Eldritch Horror Jigsaw Puzzle
Dark Alien Statue of an Ancient Eldritch Horror Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$116.00
Dark Skin Black Girl Angel Angelcore Jigsaw Puzzle
Dark Skin Black Girl Angel Angelcore Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$80.40
The Lake Fairy Princess (by Kimon Loghi) Jigsaw Puzzle
The Lake Fairy Princess (by Kimon Loghi) Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$125.00
The Nightmare (by Henry Fuseli) Jigsaw Puzzle
The Nightmare (by Henry Fuseli) Jigsaw Puzzle
Price$137.00

The Zazzle Promise

  • Order with Confidence

    If something goes wrong on our end, we'll make it right, on every order. Learn more!

  • Easy International Delivery

    Hassle-free shipping with no surprise fees. We cover any customs & duties.

  • Secure Shopping Guaranteed

    100% Secure payment with SSL Encryption.

Search Feedback

Did you find what you were looking for?
If you need help or have a question for Customer Service, please visit our Help Centre