Popular Religious Christmas Paper & Party Plates

251 results
Textured Blue Nativity Paper Plate
Textured Blue Nativity Paper Plate
Price$3.80
Rose Gold Christian Christmas Scripture - Add Name Paper Plate
Rose Gold Christian Christmas Scripture - Add Name Paper Plate
Price$3.75
Merry Christmas Paper Plate
Merry Christmas Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Illustration of Angels Paper Plate
Illustration of Angels Paper Plate
Price$3.75
O Holy Night, Christmas Carol Red Poinsettia Paper Plate
O Holy Night, Christmas Carol Red Poinsettia Paper Plate
Price$4.20
Collection
Isaiah 9:6 He will be called Wonderful...Christmas Paper Plate
Isaiah 9:6 He will be called Wonderful...Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.45
O Come Let Us Adore Him Christmas Red Floral Paper Plate
O Come Let Us Adore Him Christmas Red Floral Paper Plate
Price$4.20
Collection
Botticelli - The Nativity Paper Plate
Botticelli - The Nativity Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Knitted Angel Ugly Christmas Sweater Knitting Blue Paper Plate
Knitted Angel Ugly Christmas Sweater Knitting Blue Paper Plate
Price$3.85
Psalm 46:10 Be still and know I am God Christmas Paper Plate
Psalm 46:10 Be still and know I am God Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.45
JESUS The Greatest Gift of All John 3:16 Christmas Paper Plate
JESUS The Greatest Gift of All John 3:16 Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.45
Adoration of the shepherds - Honthorst - Christmas Paper Plate
Adoration of the shepherds - Honthorst - Christmas Paper Plate
Price$3.75
Christmas Carol Lyrics - O Holy Night - Large 9" Paper Plate
Christmas Carol Lyrics - O Holy Night - Large 9" Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Transform Your Space with Elegant Daisy Floral Paper Plate
Transform Your Space with Elegant Daisy Floral Paper Plate
Price$3.55
Wedding Collection
Believe Paper Plate
Believe Paper Plate
Price$3.95
'Believe' Vintage Red Poinsettia Floral Christmas Paper Plate
'Believe' Vintage Red Poinsettia Floral Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.20
Collection
Luke 2 14 Glory to God in the Highest, Christmas Paper Plate
Luke 2 14 Glory to God in the Highest, Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.45
Jesus is the Reason for the Season Christmas Angel Paper Plate
Jesus is the Reason for the Season Christmas Angel Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Luke 2:14 Glory to God in the Highest Christmas Paper Plate
Luke 2:14 Glory to God in the Highest Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.45
Christmas Nativity Birthday Party for Jesus Paper Plate
Christmas Nativity Birthday Party for Jesus Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Christmas Nativity Pembroke Welsh Corgi (red1) Fun Paper Plate
Christmas Nativity Pembroke Welsh Corgi (red1) Fun Paper Plate
Price$4.30
Three Wise Men Paper Plate
Three Wise Men Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Christmas Wreath Glory to God Bible Verse Paper Plate
Christmas Wreath Glory to God Bible Verse Paper Plate
Price$4.20
Collection
Believe Gold Stars Christmas Paper Plate
Believe Gold Stars Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Collection
Matching Blue Nativity Christmas 7" Paper Plate
Matching Blue Nativity Christmas 7" Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Luke 2:10-11 Poinsettia Christmas Scripture Paper Plate
Luke 2:10-11 Poinsettia Christmas Scripture Paper Plate
Price$3.80
They shall call His name Immanuel, Christmas Paper Plate
They shall call His name Immanuel, Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.45
Three Kings Paper Plate
Three Kings Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Paper plate with baby Jesus nativity Illustration
Paper plate with baby Jesus nativity Illustration
Price$3.75
Vintage Shoebox Party Paper Plate
Vintage Shoebox Party Paper Plate
Price$3.75
Christmas Nativity Baby Jesus Paper Plate
Christmas Nativity Baby Jesus Paper Plate
Price$3.85
2 Corinthians 9:15 Thanks be to God Christmas Paper Plate
2 Corinthians 9:15 Thanks be to God Christmas Paper Plate
Price$4.45
Cute Christmas Nativity Paper Plate
Cute Christmas Nativity Paper Plate
Price$3.75
Red Green Gold Stars Christmas Festive Party Paper Plate
Red Green Gold Stars Christmas Festive Party Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Collection
Minimalist Modern Simple Christmas Tree Paper Plate
Minimalist Modern Simple Christmas Tree Paper Plate
Price$3.75
Collection
Christmas Carol Lyrics - Came Upon Midnight - 9" Paper Plate
Christmas Carol Lyrics - Came Upon Midnight - 9" Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Christmas Carol Lyrics Away In A Manger 9" Paper Plate
Christmas Carol Lyrics Away In A Manger 9" Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Christmas Carol Lyrics - Silent Night - Large 9" Paper Plate
Christmas Carol Lyrics - Silent Night - Large 9" Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Christmas Nativity Birthday Party for Jesus Paper Plate
Christmas Nativity Birthday Party for Jesus Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Matching Blue Nativity Christmas 9" Paper Plate
Matching Blue Nativity Christmas 9" Paper Plate
Price$4.15
AWAY IN A MANGER PAPER PLATE
AWAY IN A MANGER PAPER PLATE
Price$3.80
Christmas Carol Lyrics Long Time Ago 9" Paper Plate
Christmas Carol Lyrics Long Time Ago 9" Paper Plate
Price$4.15
Peace on Earth Christmas Angel Holiday Family Paper Plate
Peace on Earth Christmas Angel Holiday Family Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Collection
Christmas Nativity Vintage Holly Berries Paper Plate
Christmas Nativity Vintage Holly Berries Paper Plate
Price$4.15
JESUS Reason for Season Paper Plate
JESUS Reason for Season Paper Plate
Price$4.55
Nativity Scene Stained Glass Paper Plates
Nativity Scene Stained Glass Paper Plates
Price$4.40
Peace Dove with Olive Leaf Christmas Paper Plate
Peace Dove with Olive Leaf Christmas Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Adoration of Shepherds Paper Plate
Adoration of Shepherds Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Black and Gold Nativity Textured Paper Plate
Black and Gold Nativity Textured Paper Plate
Price$3.80
nativity paper plate
nativity paper plate
Price$4.40
Christmas Winter Floral Bible Christian Wedding Paper Plate
Christmas Winter Floral Bible Christian Wedding Paper Plate
Price$4.20
Wedding Collection
Stockings Were Hung by Chimney • 2 Stockings Paper Plate
Stockings Were Hung by Chimney • 2 Stockings Paper Plate
Price$4.35
Personalised Christmas Verse Typography Green Paper Plate
Personalised Christmas Verse Typography Green Paper Plate
Price$4.50
Collection
Personalised Christmas Verse Typography Chalkboard Paper Plate
Personalised Christmas Verse Typography Chalkboard Paper Plate
Price$4.50
Collection
Personalised Christmas Bible Verse Typography Blue Paper Plate
Personalised Christmas Bible Verse Typography Blue Paper Plate
Price$4.50
Collection
Rustic Wood Christian Christmas Verse Typography Paper Plate
Rustic Wood Christian Christmas Verse Typography Paper Plate
Price$4.50
Collection
Three Wisemen Following a Star Paper Plate
Three Wisemen Following a Star Paper Plate
Price$3.95
Elegant Winter Floral on Green Christian Wedding Paper Plate
Elegant Winter Floral on Green Christian Wedding Paper Plate
Price$4.45
Wedding Collection
3 Wise men Paper Plate
3 Wise men Paper Plate
Price$3.60
Nativity Stained Glass Mosaic Holy Family Paper Plate
Nativity Stained Glass Mosaic Holy Family Paper Plate
Price$3.95

The Zazzle Promise

  • Love It Guarantee

    Don't love it? We'll take it back! 30-day returns “100% Love It Guarantee.”

  • Easy International Delivery

    Hassle-free shipping with no surprise fees. We cover any customs & duties.

  • Secure Shopping Guaranteed

    100% Secure payment with SSL Encryption.

Search Feedback

Did you find what you were looking for?
If you need help or have a question for Customer Service, please visit our Help Centre