By remaining on the Site or clicking “OK,” you consent to Zazzle’s Terms of Use and Privacy Notice, and to Zazzle’s use of cookies and similar technologies (including those provided by third parties), which retain information to enable the Zazzle experience, track interactions, advertise, and for other related purposes. You may opt-out of this tracking by updating your cookies preferences.

Save up to 25% on Select Cards & Invitations* Shop Now ➞

Love It or We'll Take Back! 30-Day Returns Guaranteed *

Search for products or designs

WeddingsOpens a menu with links to top wedding-related pages.

Wedding Invitations ➞
Wedding Stationery ➞
Be My Bridesmaid Cards
Bridal Shower Invites
Enclosure Cards
Engagement Party Invites
Hen Party Invitations
Reception Invites
RSVP Cards
Save the Dates
Thank You Cards
Wedding Décor ➞
Guest Books
Menus
Napkins
Place Cards
Plates
Programs
Seating Charts
Wedding Signs
Table Numbers
Favour Packaging ➞
Beer Labels
Can Coolers
Favour Bags
Favour Tags
Magnets
Stickers & Labels
Water Labels
Wine Bottle Labels
Showers & Parties ➞
Bridal Shower Supplies
Hen Party Supplies
Wedding Gifts ➞
Bridesmaid Gifts
Groomsmen Gifts

All Weddings ➞

Wedding Stationery & Décor
From save the dates to signage, design every detail of your day.

Invitations & StationeryOpens a menu with links to top invitations & stationery-related pages.

Birthday Invitations ➞
Kids' Birthday Invitations
Adult Birthday Invitations
Joint Birthday Invitations
1st Birthday Invitations

Baby Invitations ➞
Baby Shower Invitations
Birth Announcements
More Invitations ➞
Christening Invitations
Christmas Invitations
Communion Invitations
Graduation Invitations
Halloween Invitations
Moving Announcements
Party Invitations
Greeting Cards ➞
Anniversary Cards
Birthday Cards
Christmas Cards
Father's Day Cards
Graduation Cards
Mother's Day Cards
New Baby Cards
Thank You Cards
Valentine's Cards
Personal Stationery ➞
Note Cards
Postcards
Post-it® Notes

Mailing Accessories ➞
Envelopes
Envelope Seals
Return Address Labels
Rubber Stamps & Ink

All Invitations & Stationery ➞

Cards & Invitations 
Personalise premium stationery for any event or milestone.

Gift Wrap & Party SuppliesOpens a menu with links to top crafts & party supplies-related pages.

Gift Wrapping ➞
Gift Bags
Gift Tags
Ribbon
Stickers & Labels
Tissue Paper
Wrapping Paper
Party Signs ➞
Backdrops
Banners
Posters & Prints
Party Stationery ➞
Guest Books
Menus
Place Cards
Programs
Table Numbers
Party Tableware ➞
Paper Cups
Paper Bowls
Paper Napkins
Paper Plates
Favours & Packaging ➞
Can Coolers
Favour Bags
Favour Boxes
Favour Tags
Food & Drink Labels

All Gift Wrap & Party ➞

Gift Wrap & Party Supplies
Make their day with personalised wrapping & party decorations.

Business EssentialsOpens a menu with links to top office & school-related pages.

Business Cards ➞
Bakery Business Cards
Beauty Business Cards
Construction Business Cards
DJ Business Cards
Hair Stylist Business Cards
QR Code Business Cards
Name Tags & Badges ➞
Marketing Materials ➞
Appointment Cards
Brochures
Flyers
Gift Certificates
Loyalty Cards
Menus & Price Lists
Referral Cards
Displays & Packaging ➞
Display Cards
Hang Tags & Inserts
Product Labels

Business Stationery ➞
Notebooks
Post-it® Notes
Rubber Stamps & Ink
Business Signs ➞
Banners
Posters & Prints
Window Decals

Calendars ➞

All Business ➞

Business Essentials
Boost your brand with quality business cards & marketing materials.

Art & HomeOpens a menu with links to more categories of top pages.

Mugs ➞
Funny Mugs
Photo Mugs

Barware ➞
Beer Glasses
Can Coolers
Shot Glasses
Whiskey Glasses
Wine Glasses
More Homeware ➞
Aprons
Blankets
Christmas Tree Decorations
Cushions
Posters & Prints ➞
Abstract Posters
Botanical Posters
Fine Art Posters
Nursery Posters
Travel Posters
Vintage Posters

Art & Home 
Style your space with personalised posters, cushions, mugs & more.

T-Shirts & Accessories

T-Shirts ➞
Men's T-Shirts
Women's T-Shirts

Birthday T-Shirts
Funny T-Shirts
Photo T-Shirts
Vintage T-Shirts
Wedding T-Shirts
Accessories ➞
Badges
Beach Towels
Hats
Luggage Tags
Socks
Ties
Tote Bags
Sports & Games ➞
Golf Balls
Playing Cards
Puzzles

T-Shirts, Tote Bags & More
From business to birthdays to bridal showers, customise items for any occasion.

Create Your OwnOpens a menu with links to top Create-Your-Own products.

T-Shirts & Accessories
Badges
Hats
Socks
Ties
Tote Bags
T-Shirts

Sports & Games
Golf Balls
Playing Cards
Puzzles
Art & Home
Aprons
Blankets
Christmas Tree Decorations
Cushions
Mugs
Posters
Gift Wrap & Party
Paper Napkins
Party Signs
Stickers
Wrapping Paper
Business
Business Cards
Flyers
ID Badges
Post-it® Notes
Invitations & Stationery
Greeting Cards
Guest Books
Invitations
Menus
Programs
Return Address Labels
Rubber Stamps
Save the Dates

All Create Your Own ➞

Create Your Own
Make your own mugs, t-shirts & more with our easy design tool.

Peanut butter and jelly

Popular Butter Badges & Pins

240 results

쎃

쎃

Circle...

Square...

Rectangle...

$5 to $15

$15 to $25

Prophoto...

David Rumsey Map Collection ...

Size

Style

Shape

Price

Design Style

Officially Licensed

Special Picks

Events & Occasions

Recipients

Creator Store

Makers

Design Options

Number of Photos

Design Colour

Sort by:

Peanut Butter and Jelly National Day April 2nd Fun 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.30

100% Dairy Free 3 Cm Round Badge

Price$6.55

Sunflower Wedding Badge Button for Wedding Party

Price$8.70

Wedding Collection

Strive To Be a Butter Person Button

Price$10.90

Just Beachy Wedding 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.30

But-ter Cookie Funny Food Pun 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$8.55

Floral Freshly Squeezed Pink Lemon Bridal Shower 3 Cm Round Badge

Price$6.35

Wedding Collection

Bride & Groom Daisy Button

Price$9.35

Tropical Isle Father of the Bride Teal ID581 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.95

Wedding Collection

Tropical Isle Mother of the Groom Teal ID581 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.95

Wedding Collection

Tropical Isle Father of the Groom Teal ID581 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.95

Wedding Collection

Tropical Isle Mother of the Bride Teal ID581 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.95

Wedding Collection

Sunflower Wedding Badge Button for Wedding Party

Price$12.95

Wedding Collection

Ghee Whiz Button

Price$9.35

Sunflower Wedding Badge Button for Wedding Party

Price$12.95

Wedding Collection

Peanut Butter Lover’s Month, peanut butter toast 7.5 Cm Round Badge

Price$9.50

Valentine Peanut Butter and Jelly 15 Cm Square Badge

Price$8.70

Collection

Peanut Free Zone Gifts 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

National Peanut Butter & Jelly Day 7.5 Cm Round Badge

Price$9.50

Peanut Butter and Jelly Day April 2nd Button

Price$7.30

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwiches 3 Cm Round Badge

Price$5.75

You've Just Buttered Your Last Biscuit Cowboy Cat 3 Cm Round Badge

Price$5.75

Happy Toast Kawaii Buttered Bread Slice 7.5 Cm Round Badge

Price$9.50

Pennsylvania Dutch Canned Apple Butter Amish Food 7.5 Cm Round Badge

Price$9.90

Well Butter My Butt And Call Me A Biscuit 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$8.75

Peanut Butter And Jelly Couple Matching Halloween 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Buttered Toast Cartoon Character Happy Bread 15 Cm Square Badge

Price$8.15

Pancake Week 7.5 Cm Round Badge

Price$9.50

Nice And Toasty Cute Toast And Butter Pun 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$8.55

BUTTER Together Movie Popcorn 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$8.75

National Peanut Butter Day, peanut butter toast 7.5 Cm Round Badge

Price$9.50

Happy Icecream add name website social media 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.30

Peanut Butter Funny Peanut Butter Lovers Apparel 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Butter on toast 3 cm round badge

Price$7.55

Cute Peanut Butter Heart Jelly Cartoon Buttons

Price$8.15

Collection

I Am The Storm Suicide Prevention Awareness Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

I'm A Survivor Suicide Prevention Awareness Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

I Wear Purple For My Dad Overdose Awareness Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Preschool Is My Jam Peanut Butter Jelly Teacher 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

I'm A Survivor Suicide Prevention Awareness Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Better Together With Butter Insrational Funny Quot 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Its Ok Not To Be Ok Mental Health Awareness Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Its Ok Not To Be Ok Mental Health Awareness Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

You've Just Buttered Your Last Biscuit Funny Cowbo 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Funny Peanut Butter-jelly Friends Cute Food Matchi 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

I am the storm Suicide Prevention Awareness Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Nashville Butter Butt Biscuit, 3 Inch Round Button

Price$9.50

Fancy Some Pan-cakes Funny LGBTQ Pansexual Pride 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Plain Waffle Button

Price$5.45

Chocolate Waffle 3 Cm Round Badge

Price$5.45

Peanut Butt-er Peanut Pun Button Pin

Price$10.05

pb and j 6 cm round badge

Price$8.75

Vintage Food, Green Bean Casserole with Butter 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$8.70

Peanut Butter And Jelly Matching Couple Halloween 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$13.05

Peanut Butter Pi Button

Price$7.25

Buttermilk Pi Button

Price$7.25

Yellow Swirls 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$9.35

Buff (solid colour) 3 cm round badge

Price$5.45

Butter Yellow Solid Colour Classic Elegant 6 Cm Round Badge

Price$7.30

Butter Yellow Solid Colour 3 Cm Round Badge

Price$5.35

Still can't find what you're looking for?

쎂Previous 1 2 3 4

Peanut butter and jelly

The Zazzle Promise

Love It Guarantee
Don't love it? We'll take it back! 30-day returns “100% Love It Guarantee.”
Easy International Delivery
Hassle-free shipping with no surprise fees. We cover any customs & duties.
Secure Shopping Guaranteed
100% Secure payment with SSL Encryption.

Search Feedback

Did you find what you were looking for?

YesNo

If you need help or have a question for Customer Service, please visit our Help Centre

Get Exclusive Offers

Get exclusive offers by signing up to our mailing list. Enter your email address.

About
Press
Careers

My Account
Track my order
Return Policy
Help

Sell on Zazzle
Ambassador Program

Sitemap
Blog
Content Filter:

Choose a region and language

User Agreement | Privacy Notice